Unveiling the Unexpected: The Astonishing Diets of Early Humans 3.5 Million Years Ago

The discussion around when our forebears began consuming meat has taken an unpredicted turn. While early human evolution has long been linked with meat intake, a recent investigation unveils that some of our earliest ancestors adhered to a predominantly plant-based diet.

The study was spearheaded by Dr. Tina Lüdecke from the Max Planck Institute for Chemistry in Germany, in partnership with researchers from South Africa.

The results contest our earlier beliefs about early hominin diets.

Teeth provide insights into ancient diets

A group of researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Chemistry in Germany and the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits University) in South Africa scrutinized nitrogen isotopes in the fossilized tooth enamel of seven Australopithecus specimens.

These fossils were excavated from the Sterkfontein Caves near Johannesburg, a site abundant in early hominin remains.

By contrasting these isotopic signatures with those of contemporaneous fauna—including herbivores like antelopes and monkeys, as well as carnivores such as hyenas and big felines—the scientists delineated the positioning of Australopithecus within the prehistoric food chain.

The nitrogen isotope ratios in the Australopithecus teeth consistently exhibited low levels, closely mirroring those of plant-eating species. This strongly implies that these early human ancestors predominantly fed on a plant-based diet and did not frequently consume meat.

While the researchers concede that Australopithecus might have sporadically ingested animal proteins such as eggs or insects, their results suggest that meat did not constitute a significant portion of their diet.

Plant-based versus meat diets

The essence of this discovery is rooted in the examination of nitrogen isotopes, which serve as reliable indicators of an animal’s diet. Upon digesting food, an animal’s body processes nitrogen, leaving distinct chemical markers.

Specifically, the ratio of heavier nitrogen isotopes (15N) to lighter counterparts (14N) increases up the food hierarchy.

Herbivores which consume flora possess lower nitrogen isotope ratios, while carnivores exhibit elevated ratios due to their herbivore diet.

“Tooth enamel is the toughest tissue in mammals and retains the isotopic signature of an animal’s diet for millions of years,” remarked geochemist Tina Lüdecke.

Nitrogen isotopes expose ancient diets

Through measuring nitrogen isotope ratios in fossilized tooth enamel, researchers can ascertain if an organism primarily dined on plants or animals.

Although this technique has been extensively applied to study the diets of contemporary animals and humans, it was previously limited to fossils merely tens of thousands of years old due to the decay of organic material over spans of time.

Nevertheless, Lüdecke and her colleagues utilized a groundbreaking technique formulated in Alfredo Martínez-García’s lab at the Max Planck Institute for Chemistry. This approach enabled researchers to derive nitrogen isotope data from fossilized tooth enamel that is millions of years old.

Meat’s evolution within diets

This study has an essential implication, questioning existing theories regarding the significance of meat in human development.

Numerous researchers hypothesized that the consumption of animal resources, particularly meat, played an essential role in the evolution of larger brains and more sophisticated tool-making skills.

The protein and fat found in meat have been connected to the evolutionary growth in brain size observed in later hominins. However, concrete evidence regarding when meat became a staple in human nourishment has been elusive.

Australopithecus abstained from meat consumption

The results from this investigation imply that Australopithecus did not habitually hunt or consume sizable mammals, in contrast to Neanderthals, who inhabited later periods and actively sought large prey.

This indicates that the transition toward a meat-inclusive diet transpired later in human evolution, likely alongside the emergence of the genus Homo.

“This technique unveils thrilling avenues for understanding human development,” stated Martínez-García. “It holds the potential to address pivotal inquiries, such as when did our ancestors commence incorporating meat into their diet? And was the initiation of meat consumption correlated with an increase in brain volume?”

Significant advancement in dietary research

This study symbolizes a considerable breakthrough in the examination of ancient diets. Prior investigations depended on indirect evidence, such as tool utilization and wear marks on teeth, to infer the eating habits of early hominins.

Nonetheless, by directly measuring nitrogen isotopes in fossilized tooth enamel, Lüdecke’s team has provided the most concrete evidence thus far that Australopithecuswas mainly herbivorous.

“This research represents a significant step in enhancing our ability to decode the diets and trophic levels of all animals back across millions of years. The study confirms that its diet had negligible amounts of meat,” stated Professor Dominic Stratford, director of research at the Sterkfontein Caves.

“We are privileged that the pioneering application of this novel method took place at Sterkfontein, a site that continues to yield fundamental contributions to science even 89 years post the discovery of the first hominin fossils by Robert Broom.”

Prospective research avenues

Lüdecke’s team is now set to broaden their inquiry by analyzing fossilized tooth enamel from various early hominin species across diverse timeframes and geographical areas.

By gathering information from key fossil sites in eastern and southern Africa as well as Southeast Asia, they aspire to elucidate when and how meat consumption became a regular aspect of the human diet.

This research could aid in answering long-standing questions regarding whether the adoption of meat provided an evolutionary edge.

Did meat consumption foster the evolution of larger brains? Did it influence social structures and hunting behaviors? These are the kinds of inquiries that upcoming studies aim to explore.

The investigation, funded by the Max Planck Society and backed by the German Research Foundation’s Emmy Noether program, signifies a substantial progress in the field of paleoanthropology.

By employing advanced scientific methodologies on ancient fossils, researchers are now capable of revealing new insights regarding the dietary practices of our distant ancestors.

Meat and the sustenance of human forebears

The results from this analysis contest long-standing beliefs regarding early human diets. Rather than being primitive hunters, Australopithecus seems to have depended chiefly on plant-based nutrition.

This research illuminates how human dietary practices evolved over millions of years and underscores the importance of ongoing investigation in the realm of evolutionary anthropology.

As scientists refine their techniques and expand their datasets, we may soon uncover even more details about the dietary practices that have influenced the trajectory of human evolution.

One certainty is that our transformation from plant eaters to omnivorous beings was not as simple as previously assumed.

The research is documented in the journal Science.

—–

Appreciate what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for captivating articles, exclusive material, and the latest updates. 

Discover us on EarthSnap, a free application provided by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–