Is there an enormous undiscovered planet on the outer reaches of the Solar System? The concept has been round since earlier than the invention of Pluto within the Thirties. Labelled as planet X, outstanding astronomers had put it ahead as an evidence for Uranus’s orbit, which drifts from the trail of orbital movement that physics would anticipate it to comply with. The gravitational pull of an undiscovered planet, a number of occasions bigger than Earth, was seen as a attainable purpose for the discrepancy.
That thriller was finally defined by a recalculation of Neptune’s mass within the Nineties, however then a new theory of a possible planet 9 was put ahead in 2016 by astronomers Konstantin Batygin and Mike Brown at Caltech (the California Institute of Technology).
Associated Press
Their concept pertains to the Kuiper Belt, a large belt of dwarf planets, asteroids and different matter that lies past Neptune (and contains Pluto). Many Kuiper Belt objects – additionally known as trans-Neptunian objects – have been discovered orbiting the Sun, however like Uranus they don’t achieve this in a continuous expected direction. Batygin and Brown argued that one thing with a big gravitational pull should be affecting their orbit, and proposed planet 9 as a possible clarification.
This can be akin to what occurs with our personal Moon. It orbits the Sun each 365.25 days, according to what you’ll anticipate in view of their distance aside. However, the Earth’s gravitational pull is such that the Moon additionally orbits the planet each 27 days. From the perspective of an outdoor observer, the Moon strikes in a spiralling movement in consequence. Similarly, many objects within the Kuiper Belt present indicators of their orbits being affected by extra than simply the Sun’s gravity.
While astronomers and area scientists have been initially sceptical in regards to the planet 9 concept, there was mounting evidence because of more and more highly effective observations that the orbits of trans-Neptunian objects are certainly erratic. As Brown said in 2024:
I believe it is vitally unlikely that P9 doesn’t exist. There are at present no different explanations for the results that we see, nor for the myriad different P9-induced results we see on the Solar System.
In 2018, for instance, it was introduced that there was a brand new candidate for a dwarf planet orbiting the Sun, referred to as 2017 OF201. This object measures round 700km throughout (Earth is roughly 18x greater) and has a extremely elliptical orbit. This lack of a roughly circular orbit across the Sun recommended both an influence early in its lifetime that put it on this path, or gravitational affect from planet 9.
Problems with the idea
On the opposite hand, if planet 9 exists, why hasn’t anybody discovered it but? Some astronomers query whether or not there’s enough orbital data from Kuiper objects to justify any conclusions about its existence, whereas various explanations get put ahead for his or her movement, such because the impact of a ring of debris or the extra fantastical concept of a small black hole.
The largest situation, nevertheless, is that the outer Solar System simply hasn’t been noticed for lengthy sufficient. For instance, object 2017 OF201 has an orbital interval of about 24,000 years. While an object’s orbital path across the Sun might be present in a brief variety of years, any gravitational results in all probability want 4 to 5 orbits to note any delicate modifications.
New discoveries of objects within the Kuiper Belt have additionally introduced challenges for the planet 9 concept. The latest is named 2023 KQ14, an object found by the Subaru telescope in Hawaii.
It is named a “sednoid”, which means it spends most of its time far-off from the Sun, although inside the huge space during which the Sun has a gravitational pull (this space lies some 5,000AU or astronomical models away, the place 1AU is the space from the Earth to the Sun). The object’s classification as a sednoid additionally means the gravitational affect of Neptune has little to no impact on it.
2023 KQ14’s closest method to the Sun is round 71AU away, whereas its furthest level is about 433AU. By comparability, Neptune is about 30AU away from the Sun. This new object is one other with a really elliptical orbit, however it’s stabler than 2017 OF201, which means that no giant planet, together with a hypothetical planet 9, is considerably affecting its path. If planet 9 exists, it will subsequently maybe need to be farther than 500AU away from the Sun.
Wikimedia
To make issues worse for the planet 9 concept, that is the fourth sednoid to be found. The other three additionally exhibit secure orbits, equally suggesting that any planet 9 must be very far-off certainly.
Nonetheless, the chance stays there may nonetheless be an enormous planet affecting the orbits of our bodies inside the Kuiper Belt. But astronomers’ means to search out any such planet stays considerably restricted by the restrictions of even unmanned area journey. It would take 118 years for a spacecraft to journey far sufficient away to search out it, primarily based on estimates from the velocity of Nasa’s New Horizons explorer.
This means we’ll need to proceed to depend on ground- and space-based telescopes to detect something. New asteroids and distant objects are being found on a regular basis as our observing capabilities change into extra detailed, which ought to progressively shed extra gentle on what is likely to be on the market. So watch this (very large) area, and let’s see what emerges within the coming years.
Get your information from precise specialists, straight to your inbox. Sign up to our daily newsletter to obtain all The Conversation UK’s newest protection of stories and analysis, from politics and enterprise to the humanities and sciences.