Households owed hundreds as photograph studio’s proprietor battles sickness and chapter

A Wellington images studio has closed, leaving a number of households ready on portraits they paid hundreds of {dollars} for and its proprietor going through monetary and emotional misery.

Vivid Photography founder Matthew Newall stated an ideal storm of mounting debt, post-Covid financial pressure, a studio relocation and a few severe well being points compelled the closure, which he described because the collapse of his life’s work.

But clients stated they felt deserted, with some turning to authorized motion to attempt to get well their cash and contacting Fair Go with their considerations.

Seven households who spoke to 1News say they collectively paid near $12,000 for photograph packages final 12 months however by no means acquired their portraits or a refund.

Sue Culver, a longtime buyer of almost 20 years, stated she initially made a deposit for a portrait package deal in November of final 12 months, following a household shoot in October. She paid off the $3200 steadiness in March.

“We ordered a whole lot more than we had anticipated, but we thought ‘this is probably the last one that we’re going to order with the kids, as the four of us’,” she stated.

It was after finishing the cost that Culver says she started attempting to contact the studio by way of e mail and cellphone.

“I’ve tried on WhatsApp, which has been received but not been seen, and on Facebook Messenger it’s also been delivered, but not read.”

She stated she was “genuinely concerned” for Newall’s wellbeing and was “giving him the benefit of the doubt”, however her considerations developed additional when a buddy directed her to a Facebook group asking if anybody else had skilled points with Vivid Photography.

“Then, when I started to read about other people’s experiences, I had that kind of sick feeling of ‘please don’t tell me we’ve lost over $3000’,” she stated.

Studio went silent

Other households described picture-perfect shoots and viewings, however some stated the studio went silent earlier than funds have been full – and even those that paid in full stated they have been left ready at nighttime for his or her portraits.

Follow-up emails bounced, calls went unanswered and the studio’s web site went offline.

In March, some clients acquired an e mail from Newall citing ongoing well being points and asserting the enterprise was closing, doubtlessly getting into liquidation. The message assured households their portraits and digital information could be delivered and promised an replace by April 1.

But as of the afternoon earlier than publication, solely two of the seven clients 1News spoke to stated that they had acquired digital information.

Newall stated he had undergone seven current surgical procedures, was on a incapacity allowance as he waited for the following one and was now negotiating chapter and liquidation.

“I’m smashed. I’m destroyed,” he stated. “This is losing my whole life at this point.”

He stated communication broke down after suppliers reduce off his internet and cellphone traces attributable to unpaid payments.

“It’s an emotional product, an artistic product — quite heartbreaking,” he stated. “The intention is to get it all sorted. They’re more important to me than the landlord, the suppliers, Gem Visa or the government.”

While clients say they really feel deserted, Newall insisted he nonetheless supposed to ship. He stated the digital pictures have been the majority of the price of the packages and remained his precedence.

“In my mind, all the customers should have all their digital files from every shoot, and that’s paramount to me.

“There’s prints that I’ve bought for some which are nonetheless going to be framed, I need to do it, however within the course of, I’ve needed to have consideration on negotiating with Inland Revenue.”

Some clients pursued their cases through the Disputes Tribunal.

Julia Lindsay-Rewi, who paid $600 to Vivid Photography, said the Tribunal tried to dial Newall into the hearing but he did not answer.

“The tribunal dominated in our favour, so that they despatched him an order for him to pay us the cash again, a refund, and we have not heard something like emails or cellphone calls. He hasn’t finished something with it.”

Newall told 1News he was unaware of the ruling and did not participate in the hearing.

Disappointment

For Sarah Stephens, who paid around $700, the disappointment was more than just money.

“This was meant to be a reminiscence for my youngsters as they become older – of me with them. Now I have never bought something to indicate for that,” she said.

Jenny Savage, who paid just over $3000, said even if she were to receive the photos, they would be “tainted” by the whole situation.

“It feels a bit like a little bit of a slap within the face. Our fundamental concern is we simply don’t desire it to occur to anybody else. I do not need anybody else to expertise what we have gone via.”

Culver said she hoped Newall was OK and described him as a “proficient man”.

“I’ve supplied to assist him get information and pictures out to folks so he can not less than fulfil that bit.”

Newall said he hoped to clear his debts and complete outstanding orders by the end of 2025.

“That could be enterprise closed, all finished, everybody fastened up.”

The night time earlier than this text was attributable to publish, an extra 4 of the affected clients acquired their digital information.

Have a narrative for Fair Go? Email fairgo@tvnz.co.nz