Pop Culture Happy Hour : NPR

[THEME MUSIC]

LINDA HOLMES: The Paper is a comedy instructed in a mock documentary format a couple of office that is going through monetary and cultural headwinds. If that sounds lots like The Office, properly, it is a spin-off of The Office, simply barely. And this time, the business within the crosshairs is native newspapers. I’m Linda Holmes, and as we speak we’re speaking about The Paper on Pop Culture Happy Hour from NPR.

HOLMES: Joining me as we speak is Ronald Young Jr. He’s the host of the movie and tv evaluation podcast Leaving the Theater. Hello, Ronald.

RONALD YOUNG JR.: Hello, Linda.

HOLMES: And additionally with us is New York Times meals reporter and creator of the best-selling cookbook Indian-ish– I like to recommend it, I’ve cooked out of it– Priya Krishna. Welcome again, Priya.

PRIYA KRISHNA: Hi, Linda.

HOLMES: All proper. Great to see you each. The Paper was co-created by Greg Daniels, who developed the US model of The Office, alongside Michael Koman, who co-created Nathan for You, which makes, like, a bizarre type of sense to me, I’ve to say. The conceit is that Dunder Mifflin was devoured by a paper conglomerate, and that conglomerate has a number of companies that use paper. And in Toledo, Ohio, one of many issues it has ended up proudly owning is the Toledo Truth Teller, a neighborhood newspaper that has turn out to be sparsely staffed and principally cuts and pastes wire tales, or on its digital facet, clickbait tales. But a brand new editor-in-chief named Ned, performed by Donald Gleeson, is available in with dedication and pluck solely to seek out that there is not lots of dedication and pluck left within the Truth Teller. The strongest particular person there’s an editor named Esmeralda, performed by Sabrina Impacciatore, who you may acknowledge because the resort supervisor within the Italy season of The White Lotus. Esmeralda doesn’t wish to share energy. She likes issues how they’re, and so she seeks to undermine Ned at each alternative, like reducing the wire service.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

NED: Sorry, I’m a bit of distracted. The wire shouldn’t be working.

ESMERALDA: Yeah. That was alleged to be a shock. But sure, I canceled it.

NED: You reduce the– you narrow the wire?

ESMERALDA: Yes, from my little workplace.

[END PLAYBACK]

HOLMES: There are allies available, although, particularly Mare, performed by Chelsea Frei, who gave up some time in the past, however want to be doing actual journalism. This setup permits for tales about chasing down native tales, making an attempt to outlive in a hostile media setting, native politics, and naturally, the ins and outs of the private dynamics among the many workers. And one member of that workers binds The Paper to The Office. Oscar Nunez is again enjoying Oscar Martinez, who’s now a jaded accountant in an entire new messy state of affairs. There are 10 episodes of The Paper streaming now on Peacock. Ronald, I wish to begin with you. What did you assume?

JR.: So I got here to this present very as a brilliant Office fan and expecting– you already know, I really like the mockumentary format. There’s so many different examples of this which have gone properly of the quirky workplace comedy. You have Parks and Rec, of course–

HOLMES: Yes.

JR.: –which is, like, a direct descendant of this. So I got here in, eyes vast open, able to take pleasure in one thing else. I additionally got here in as somebody who loves Abbott Elementary.

HOLMES: Yeah.

JR.: I believe it is a mid present. This– [LAUGHS] that is very mid. Having all of these examples set earlier than it, I believe this present could possibly be lots higher. That being stated, the bones of this present are excellent. And we all know that traditionally, Greg Daniels stumbles out of the gate. He stumbled out of the gate with The Office Season 1, and he stumbled out of the gate with Parks and Recreation Season 1. This additionally seems like one other stumble out of the gate–

HOLMES: Right.

JR.: –because there’s stuff and storylines and people who I like right here, however they’re all getting used incorrectly, for my part. So I did chortle, however the laughs I even had felt out of sequence. So I’d say–

HOLMES: Yeah.

JR.: –I’m, like, middling on this.

HOLMES: Yeah, I believe you make a very good level that each The Office and Parks and Rec are reveals that I believe for lots of people, they’re like, properly, you already know, the primary couple are a bit of bizarre, and so they do not feel just like the present feels later.

JR.: Yeah.

HOLMES: Priya, the place did you come down? How did you prefer it?

KRISHNA: I largely agree. I really like all the reveals that you just listed. I believe I’ve watched The Office and Parks and Recreation no less than 10 times–

JR.: Yeah. Dozens of occasions.

KRISHNA: –beginning to finish. And I believe people who find themselves coming to this present are going to expect the identical kind of form of cozy, all-enveloping consolation watch {that a} present like The Office and Parks and Recreation will be. And I’d say it, like, form of offers that.

HOLMES: Mm-hmm.

KRISHNA: I believe the premise is nice. You know, as a journalist, the premise that, like, a paper firm owns a neighborhood newspaper may be very humorous to me. I simply discovered that it, like, simply did not fairly get there, like, simply by way of the storylines, by way of the humor. Like, the characters do not match collectively as a unit in the best way that they do with these wonderful ensemble casts. Like, should you consider a present like Parks and Recreation, every of these characters may have had their very own spin-off present.

HOLMES: Yeah.

JR.: Yes.

KRISHNA: And I believe that is type of what–

JR.: Yes.

KRISHNA: –made that present so good.

HOLMES: Yeah.

KRISHNA: I do not really feel that method about this. I really feel like some characters are shortchanged for others. I’m very shocked at simply how a lot they’re actually making an attempt to simply reuse what has already labored. We’ve bought a grumpy man. We’ve bought the absurd caricature. We have the budding romance between two younger, white, straight folks. Domhnall does not fairly work for me as a number one character. It is likely to be as a result of I can solely consider him as his character from Ex Machina.

HOLMES: Yeah.

KRISHNA: But I’m not getting the, like, pluck and spirit that I form of need from, like, the Amy Poehler kind of determine on this present. I’ll say, the factor that labored a lot for me was Sabrina Impacciatore. I really feel that she is sort of a scene stealer on this present, and I wish to watch something along with her in it.

HOLMES: Hmm.

KRISHNA: There is an episode known as “Scam Alert” that I believe is the very best episode in all the season, the place that character is form of being scammed by somebody pretending to be Josh Holloway, the actor from Lost, and it’s so humorous. And it jogged my memory of, like, the very best episodes of The Office. I’d like to see extra of that. But I agree, there’s, like, potential right here, however it simply did not land for me.

HOLMES: It’s so fascinating to me as a result of I got here down roughly in the identical spot as each of you. But Priya, for me, Esmeralda is the factor that retains the present from working.

KRISHNA: Wow.

JR.: I agree.

HOLMES: I believe she is method too broad. There is method an excessive amount of of her. It is not possible for me to know how she would nonetheless have a job. She is incompetent. And she can be type of making an attempt to undermine everybody who works there. I do not perceive. I believe you possibly can go as much as a sure point– and I discovered this generally with The Office as properly. I believe you possibly can go as much as a sure level with folks being absurd, after which it simply turns into, like, too absurd. And I believe out of the gate along with her, she’s too absurd. It’s nothing in opposition to the actress. I actually preferred her in The White Lotus. I do not assume she’s doing something apart from precisely what they’ve requested her to do. But I believe she has written method too broad. I do assume this present, I began out feeling like, yeah, you already know, the notes are clearly very acquainted, and I do not essentially assume that is a horrible factor. I believe while you see spin-offs like, you already know, Angel and Buffy or– you already know, I imply, each James Bond film has related components. It’s like, you possibly can return to what makes your factor work. That’s wonderful. But I used to be feeling type of mad about it, and I used to be like, I do not know if this actually has me. But then I’d say the final two episodes of the season, I used to be like, oh, they did get me, truly. I truly do care about this. [LAUGHS] And I truly do like these folks. And I believe Domhnall Gleeson, I preferred him on this. I believed he was very charming on this.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

NED: When I used to be a child, I did not wish to be Superman. I needed to be Clark Kent as a result of, to me, Clark is the true superhero. He’s saving the world, too, by working at a newspaper. And that, to me, is way more noble and way more achievable.

[END PLAYBACK]

HOLMES: It’s an fascinating he is the boss, however he is not– he is each type of a bit of bit buffoony, however he is additionally type of your– your main man. He’s very earnest. He clearly means very properly. And he is not unhealthy at his job. He’s simply type of vulnerable to bumbling type of stuff. [LAUGHS] I actually loved him lots. And I actually like Chelsea Frei on this. I believe she’s bought a very grounded high quality that I actually felt prefer it kept– I felt like she stored type of bringing it again all the way down to earth a bit of bit when it will get terribly foolish with the Esmeralda stuff.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

MARE: I’ve an thought.

ESMERALDA: Oh my God! How lengthy have you ever been there?

MARE: The entire time.

ESMERALDA: I believed you had been a pile of shirts.

SPEAKER: [GROANS] Yes, Mare.

[END PLAYBACK]

HOLMES: I believe all of us landed someplace within the center, however for actually totally different causes. Like, my feeling has been, like, if they do not tone down Esmeralda– which they nonetheless might– then I’m going to finally lose curiosity on this present as a result of I am unable to do this this a lot.

JR.: I believe the problem with the Esmeralda character is that she is written too broadly. I agree with you, Linda. But I additionally agree with you, Priya, that she is seasoning to all the present. She brings that type of chaos agent that we’d like for a present like this. If you have a look at Abbott Elementary, should you have a look at Ava Coleman– who’s out of this agent of chaos, however she additionally cares concerning the students– she has some form of coronary heart of gold that type of endears you to her. If you have a look at Dwight Schrute, he’s an agent of chaos, however he is also an excellent salesman. And you truly like him. There’s lots of elements about his character that make him extraordinarily likable. He has this ethical code that is smart to him. With Esmeralda, she’s a foul mother. She is sabotaging everyone on the paper. And she also– like, she usually does not care about journalism. And so while you put all of these on her after which additionally attempt to make us chortle at her jokes– there was stuff that she stated that I used to be like, I do not assume that is humorous since you’re being a jerk. And I’m hoping that in season 2, they understand what they’ve with Esmeralda and type of hone it down, or no less than, like, slim the main focus a bit of bit.

KRISHNA: I believe that is why I preferred “The Scam Alert” episode a lot as a result of the end–

JR.: Yes, vulnerability.

KRISHNA: –really humanizes her.

JR.: Yes. Yes.

KRISHNA: You know, you’re feeling actually unhealthy for her. You perceive why she is that this, like, massive, larger-than-life character. And I– yeah, I hope to get extra of these moments.

JR.: Yeah.

HOLMES: I believe that is honest. And I do assume that that episode is humorous. I loved “The Scam Alert” component of that. And I loved the Josh Holloway component, which, like, good job, Josh Holloway.

JR.: Yes.

[LAUGHTER]

JR.: You bought him for this?

KRISHNA: Yeah.

[LAUGHTER]

HOLMES: And it is in all probability not going to shock anyone, given me and who I’m and what I’m recognized to love, that I used to be form of drawn to the rom-com components of this, this type of form of flirtation between Ned and Mare that takes a very long time to type of begin to be something. And at first, I used to be like, oh, I do not know if I wish to watch this as a result of, in fact, he’s her boss, which he is tremendous, tremendous aware of, which, no less than, that helps a bit of bit that, you already know, this isn’t one thing that’s unstated or unacknowledged, or, like, no person cares about it. As they bought to the top of the season, I used to be like, I truly did really feel like their capacity to type of be taught to cooperate with one another.

KRISHNA: Right.

HOLMES: And I believe one of many issues that I believe works on this present that wasn’t a part of The Office is that one of many issues that made The Office genuinely a melancholic present was that no person there cared about something they had been doing, except–

JR.: Yes.

HOLMES: –for the needs of, like, a type of a really indifferent, like, I imagine in being good at my job, like–

KRISHNA: Right.

HOLMES: –which is form of how a few of them had been. It’s type of how Michael was. It’s type of how Dwight was. It’s vital to be good at your job. These folks truly are attempting to do one thing that they assume is significant. And I believe that doubtlessly does give the present some extra form and a few extra depth. And I believe they begin to get into that near the top of the season while you understand that these individuals are form of afraid to confess that they’ve pleasure of their work as a result of they really feel like if I admit that I’ve pleasure in my work and that I care how different folks obtain my work, it is going to simply disappoint me in the long run, proper? Because it is simply simpler to not care about your job, which is, I believe one thing that lots of people have felt at totally different occasions. So like, by the top, when it began to select up these threads a bit of bit extra, I did prefer it. One of the issues that The Office has in widespread with this present is also that there’s a massive group of type of people that work in The Office who do not do lots, who aren’t introduced into lots of tales.

KRISHNA: Right.

HOLMES: Alex Edelman is on this and I believe is great and really humorous as this man who simply type of sits at his desk [LAUGHS] and thinks about all the youngsters he has at residence. And I like him very a lot. I believe he is form of the supporting one who’s working the very best for me.

KRISHNA: But I do assume that this present makes the error that season 1 of The Office made, the place it was like, we’re actually solely going to spend money on these few characters’ storylines on the expense of all of those different character storylines, though now we have an incredible ensemble forged.

HOLMES: Yeah.

KRISHNA: And then I believe a part of what made The Office so nice is that it began to comprehend, oh my God, like, our ensemble is wonderful. We must spend money on all of those characters.

HOLMES: Yeah. I believe that is proper.

JR.: Yes.

KRISHNA: I additionally am, like, charmed by the Mare-Ned romance, however I’m additionally similar to, I really feel like because of this, the Nicole-Detrick romance, I’m form of caught being like, what is occurring right here? Who are these folks? But I really feel like perhaps that is simply, like, a Greg Daniels signature that now we have to attend till season 2 to see untangled.

HOLMES: It’s one more reason why if they’d had 22 episodes, like a broadcast season, I really feel like perhaps you’d have seen extra of these characters begin to get extra form to them as a result of they do have lots of promise. You know, you talked about Melvin Gregg as Detrick, who I believe is actually humorous, and Ramona Young, who performs Nicole. And the 2 of them type of have– it isn’t a flirtation precisely. It’s like an entire different bizarre type of works for them, type of perhaps, form of factor happening. And I did– I did like them. I’m all the time glad to see Oscar Nunez once more. I believe he nonetheless understands the way to make this precise man humorous.

KRISHNA: Yeah.

HOLMES: He’s the place the place they permit him to bask in a bit of little bit of sometimes type of callback humor.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

OSCAR: God. Not once more. I’m not agreeing to any of this. Don’t you guys have sufficient after 9 years? Nobody needs this. You know what? You cannot use my voice, my likeness, my face, nothing.

[END PLAYBACK]

HOLMES: They do not do lots of direct referencing of The Office, aside from the occasional, like, Oscar will sometimes say one thing, and so they’ll be like, oh, he is speaking about Michael. Those issues had been enjoyable to me. But I– I do share your sense that, like, it is within the center. It’s nice. It’s wonderful. I truly do not suggest bingeing it, essentially. I’d watch it a bit of bit at a time. I’m unsure it is a bingey present. I believe that as a bingey show–

KRISHNA: Yeah.

HOLMES: –it type of began to get a bit of, yeah, OK, I bought it, I bought it. Whereas after I would sit all the way down to it once more, I’d be like, oh, OK, that is enjoyable. This is cheerful.

JR.: I agree with the episode rely. I believe the profit that lots of– that every other tv present has is that– and particularly should you go to The Office particularly, should you return and rewatch it, it rewards you for saying that we thought of this. We thought of these gradual burns. Like, should you simply return and watch Jim and Pam and simply have a look at Jim’s face each time Roy is round, they thought of that. Look how Jim feels on this second. And this one, I did just like the Ned and Mare romance. And in direction of the top, I did prefer it as a result of he immediately addresses the truth that he’s her boss, and there is some battle in him combating that earlier than, you already know, they proceed exploring or deciding what they’ll do at that time. It additionally feels prefer it’s pressured. It seems like they’re making me cope with this romance as a result of each different present that’s like this has a romance on the heart. And I do not thoughts it, that being there. I like romantic comedies. But I really feel like while you put them in The Paper, within the very first episode, you get– these two. There it’s.

HOLMES: Oh, positive.

JR.: That’s what it’s.

HOLMES: Oh, positive.

JR.: Those two, we’ll watch that.

HOLMES: Sure.

JR.: But then it additionally feels unfocused, in a method, as a result of, like, there is no Roy. You know what I imply? Like, there is no method that we’re, like, pulling them aside, aside from these type of, like, false obstacles. So, like, it in that method, it makes me say, what’s your plan for The Paper past season 1, particularly with all the data that listeners and us all have now, realizing what occurs in subsequent seasons of those reveals? I do not know what it’s for The Paper, particularly as a result of they actually did not spend sufficient time speaking about reporting.

HOLMES: Yeah.

KRISHNA: Right.

HOLMES: Like I stated, I did not assume they’d me. And I bought to the top of the season, and I used to be like, oh, you probably did have me, truly, on a few fronts. I bought to the very finish of it, and I used to be like, yeah, I truly do care about this. I loved this. I’m with these folks. I would like them to be glad. And I appreciated that. So tell us what you concentrate on The Paper. Find us at fb.com/pchh. That brings us to the top of our present. Priya Krishna, Ronald Young Jr., thanks each for being right here to speak about our favourite factor, journalism. Thank you each.

JR.: [LAUGHS] Thank you, Linda.

KRISHNA: Thank you, Linda.

HOLMES: This episode was produced by Janae Morris and Mike Katzif and edited by our showrunner, Jessica Reedy. And Hello Come In offers our theme music. Thanks for listening to Pop Culture Happy Hour from NPR. I’m Linda Holmes. And we’ll see you all subsequent time.

Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.

Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could fluctuate. Transcript textual content could also be revised to appropriate errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative document of NPR’s programming is the audio document.