Overconsumption of fabric items is an issue with vital penalties, from environmental crises – it’s a key driver of resource depletion – to diminished private well-being – it might lead to a host of mental health challenges. One standard reply to this downside is minimalism, a way of life that guarantees freedom and ease by lowering materials possessions. Guidebooks and standard tradition about minimalism and decluttering have introduced the idea of “less is more” into the mainstream.
But is minimalism a viable resolution to overconsumption? Research suggests it might include issues that will undermine its potential to enhance our world and ourselves.
The paradox of minimalism
Minimalism initially started as an art movement focused on simplicity, then later transitioned into a way of life. Its preliminary attraction lies in its promise of freedom from materials possessions.
Minimalism as a lifestyle movement, minimalism rapidly gained reputation within the West (predominantly within the US, Japan and Europe), the place it emerged partly as resistance to the excesses of shopper tradition. It aimed to scale back the ecological hurt of overconsumption and enhance well-being.
However, the sensible utility of minimalism reveals sudden challenges. The endowment effect makes it inherently troublesome for people to half with possessions as soon as possession is established, as their perceived worth will increase considerably. Loss aversion could make the discomfort related to a loss (eg with discarding an merchandise) extra intense than the pleasure derived from an equal achieve (eg a clutter-free area).
A distinct problem is that as consumer minimalism often becomes competitive, its adopters could try to be the “most” minimalist or personal the least. Social media platforms can flip the method right into a public efficiency, the place people showcase their sparse, curated houses and lack of litter. Yet, behind the scenes, achieving that look can entail considerable spending on, say, designer multipurpose furnishings or premium “timeless” clothes, and require ample time. So as minimalism grew to become stylish, it morphed, for some, from an anti-consuming stance into a way to signal virtue and status. A corrective for overconsumption has turn out to be one other type of conspicuous consumption, an identity project removed from its unique intent of selling private happiness and planetary well being.
Performance administration – a brand new strategy?
Performance management is a elementary enterprise administration observe that helps organisations successfully oversee and improve worker efficiency. Its core components usually embrace setting clear aims, monitoring progress, offering steady suggestions, and recognising outcomes.
Effective efficiency administration techniques use structured instruments and processes to make sure particular person efforts help broader strategic goals. These techniques cannot solely have an effect on behaviour however might also boost engagement, particularly amongst decrease performers, by clarifying expectations and providing methods for progress.
Thus, a structured strategy, such because the SMART (particular, measurable, attainable, related and time-bound) goal-setting framework, can considerably enhance the probability of reaching aims. Author Peter F. Drucker’s Management by Objectives launched the thought of aligning private and organisational targets, laying the inspiration for contemporary efficiency techniques. Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton’s Balanced Scorecard popularised the next precept: “What you measure is what you get.”
Applying efficiency administration to consumption
Applied to consumption, this framework would contain reworking particular person targets into concrete, measurable actions. Evidence from a latest article, Behavioral interventions for waste reduction: a systematic review of experimental studies, reveals that goal-setting interventions that immediate people to decide to particular targets could result in considerably better reductions in waste and useful resource use than interventions centered solely on elevating basic consciousness. Furthermore, a recent study of particular person shoppers discovered that individuals who acquired a number of interventions – together with details about environmental impression and suggestions for staying on monitor – decreased clothes purchases after one month “on average by 58.59%” within the case of particular person goal-setting and “by 46.82%” within the case of group goal-setting.
Performance administration approaches have been successfully utilized not solely in conventional organisational settings however in different domains comparable to sports and learning. Practices comparable to structured goal-setting and progress-tracking, when strengthened by way of contextual gamification, can positively influence motivation and engagement.
Marketers usually incorporate activity streaks into social platforms, loyalty applications, apps and different digital instruments to encourage and maintain engagement. The streaks introduce a meta-goal (“keep the streak alive”) on high of a process purpose (“complete today’s action”). The app MyFitnessPal goals to strengthen wholesome habits with each day streaks and progress-tracking. PocketGuard, which Forbes ranks among the top budgeting and personal finance apps, tracks spending behaviour and celebrates financial savings targets to encourage monetary self-discipline. And Duolingo, the popular language-learning app, makes use of streaks and badges to attempt to maintain customers’ motivation.
These apps share a typical design sample: they provide a easy, structured path for incremental progress, fairly than summary long-term targets. By making progress seen and rewarding consistency, they might help customers keep motivated and engaged over time.
Imagine an app that helps you handle your consumption similar to a health app helps you handle your well being. This app would goal to align your values, comparable to sustainability or economic system, with targets comparable to limiting non-essential purchases to 2 per 30 days or monitoring spending on classes like clothes and electronics. It may even reward you with factors for skipping impulse buys.
Such a framework may mirror efficiency administration and gamification ideas by offering personalised, real-time suggestions to customers concerning the environmental and personal-finance impacts of their consumption. Combined with behavioural design components comparable to progress updates, commitment-confirmation prompts, and streak rewards, the suggestions may assist information customers towards more healthy consumption habits whereas making sustainable selections extra motivating. Whereas e-commerce platforms like Shein and Temu use comparable ideas to encourage individuals to purchase extra, an anti-overconsumption app could be rewarding “buying better”.
The method ahead
While minimalism raises vital consciousness about overconsumption, its individualistic, subjective and doubtlessly aggressive adoptions restrict its effectiveness as an answer. Unlike subjective and excessive definitions of “enough”, efficiency administration rules could possibly be used to construct a structured and quantifiable atmosphere to deal with overconsumption. In different phrases, these rules might help translate summary values into concrete, achievable targets and actions.
Yet there are often some difficulties in implementing full-scale performance management systems. Data integration and computational complexity are often the key obstacles, whereas customers’ engagement, in addition to privateness and regulatory considerations, could restrict effectiveness. Thus, a extra sustainable resolution in all probability lies in combining and moderating minimalism’s moral consciousness with efficiency administration’s structured self-discipline. For advertising managers and app builders, it is a name to prioritise behavioural design for the next objective than simply rising engagement and consumption. Psychological methods and gamification rules can be utilized to encourage customers to succeed in significant targets.
It’s not sufficient to all the time be reminded that overconsumption helps to drive environmental crises and contributing to psychological well being challenges. Consumers may use sensible instruments to information more healthy, extra conscious selections that don’t require going to extremes.
A weekly e-mail in English that includes experience from students and researchers. It offers an introduction to the range of analysis popping out of the continent and considers a few of the key points going through European international locations. Get the publication!