When individuals learn how I grew up, they deal with it like an idyllic way of life. It’s a lot darker than that.

Dear Prudence is Slate’s recommendation column. Submit questions here.

Dear Prudence,

My boyfriend and I grew up in very totally different circumstances. His brother idolizes a sort of political/bodily back-to-the-land motion, just like the circumstances wherein I grew up. It drives me up the wall.

His household is from a small suburb with a light local weather and dependable public providers. I grew up in an space of the U.S. identified for remoteness and isolation. It was lovely, but additionally required bodily arduous labor from the entire household to maintain the family going. Think chopping, stacking, and splitting wooden for warmth; rigorously making ready for darkish, remoted winters with harmful temperatures; common, prolonged energy outages through the winter (my mother and father refused to get a generator); and being alone within the winter darkish with a small variety of individuals for lengthy intervals. Our group was removed from the closest hospital, so if the climate was dangerous, you simply didn’t go. My siblings and I all have stuff like weirdly healed bones from lack of medical care, though we may afford it. We simply couldn’t get to it. We weren’t off-grid, however we weren’t reliably on it both.

Now that I’m an grownup, I moved out of state and to a metropolis the place day by day life is straightforward. I miss the unimaginable great thing about my childhood, however I like my tender life. I don’t discuss it as a result of individuals from totally different backgrounds act like I grew up in 1910, or prefer it was some idyllic daydream to stay that method. My boyfriend’s brother lives together with his mother and father and talks nonstop about his dream of an off-grid home and life. Every time we go to, his brother talks at size about how excellent his life could be with out electrical energy and when he can “go back to the land.” It’s additionally paired with some regressive politics. I don’t say a lot, however it drives me insane. Life with out electrical energy isn’t romantic; it’s chilly, damp, fraught with seasonal affective dysfunction, and infants get carbon dioxide poisoning from creosote buildup within the chimney. We’re visiting in February, and I’m already dreading getting a political gross sales pitch alone childhood. How do I cope with this?

—Dazed and Confused

Dear Dazed and Confused,

I get the sense that partaking on this fantasy about off-grid dwelling is assembly a necessity to your boyfriend’s brother that has little to do with an actionable plan to fend for himself within the wilderness. I feel it’s in all probability all about imagining a world wherein he feels stronger and extra profitable than he does now, and the place he can depart behind a few of the components of his life that haven’t turned out the best way he hoped they’d. The regressive politics might need an identical origin. And I actually doubt both of his passions will change in response to info or knowledgeable views like, “It’s actually not enjoyable to go without medical care.”

If it’s in any respect attainable, attempt to see his off-grid fixation as a symptom of the type of particular person he’s and his scenario. He may simply as simply be targeted on touring to a different nation to satisfy and fall in love with a lady with “traditional family values,” or giving his life to an excessive spiritual sect that promised a richer and higher life, indifferent from all worldly possessions. It’s simpler stated than achieved, but when you may get your self into the mindset of being an observer (who could also be rolling their eyes internally and accumulating anecdotes to unpack at house later) of his habits and the place it comes from, it’d really feel much less irritating to listen to him share a wildly inaccurate perspective on a life-style you recognize nicely.

You must also begin to inform the reality about the way you grew up. While the preliminary reactions could also be annoying, sharing your expertise—the fascinating, the nice, and the actually dangerous and depressing components alike—together with your boyfriend, your folks, and even acquaintances would possibly really feel good. I say this as a result of I believe that a part of your agitation together with your boyfriend’s brother comes out of your sense of being unseen. If you felt that your expertise was understood, appreciated, and even honored in your day by day life, you might be rather a lot much less bothered by one mildly delusional, annoying man who will get all of it fallacious.

Dear Prudence,

When my husband left his telephone unattended whereas he went to the lavatory the opposite day, I made a decision to look by way of and located quite a few recordings of girls he secretly filmed out in public (asses and boobs). I haven’t stated something, however I feel that is extremely sleazy and creepy.  Do I’ve a proper to confront him though I discovered of his actions by way of questionable means?

—Married to the Biggest Boob and Ass of All

Dear Married,

Yes, you may have a proper. Your husband will nearly definitely disagree with me on that and do every part he can to take the main target off his perverted actions and focus as a substitute in your violation of his privateness. But you recognize that.

The extra essential query to ask your self might be about what you hope to attain with this confrontation. You’re not going to efficiently make him not a creep or sleazy. Is there a response he may present that would really make you’re feeling higher about what you found? I doubt it. I’m positive this isn’t the primary time he’s achieved one thing to make you query his character or really feel disgusted by his angle towards ladies (together with you!). I counsel that you simply maintain the proof, and in the event you do at some point determine to go away him, embrace it as an exhibit once you clarify your reasoning.

Prudie Wants to Hear From You!

Readers usually have nice options for our letter writers, sometimes disagree with a degree Prudie makes, or just wish to present some further recommendation. Each week, Prudie can be replying to a few of these feedback and options from readers, which can be featured on the positioning on Fridays for Slate Plus members. Write to us! Or submit a question here.

Dear Prudence,

My spouse is about to begin a warfare with our neighbor throughout the road from us for a cause that defies all logic. Our neighbor “Dylan” is a single man in his early 40s. He’s the proper neighbor—retains his yard up, his canine doesn’t bark, and he isn’t loud or impolite. Why then would my spouse probably have it in for him?

Because, in keeping with her, he has too many vehicles! Dylan has a pickup truck and two sports activities vehicles.  Typically, one of many autos can be in his storage whereas the opposite two stay in his driveway.  The truck and vehicles are stored clear, and he makes use of every of them a number of occasions per week, so that they aren’t sitting there accumulating dust. My spouse says she is “tired of looking at them” and needs to lift the problem with our householders’ affiliation. How do I cease this madness earlier than she turns Dylan towards us?

—Car Kvetching

Dear Car Kvetching,

I’ve been sitting right here making an attempt to provide you with concepts about what may actually be happening right here, making up ridiculous plots like, “She’s having an affair with Dylan and wants to stop but can’t bring herself to, so her hope is that the HOA harassment will force him to flee the neighborhood before she destroys her life” however nothing is admittedly resonating. I’m as misplaced as you might be.

The excellent news is that she will be able to report Dylan, and nothing will come of it. So you don’t need to do something however maintain an eye fixed out for different unusual and sudden fixations from her.

Classic Prudie

Last week, I used to be performing some work on our shared desktop pc whereas my husband’s private e mail was nonetheless logged in, which I didn’t notice till a notification popped up, and I caught sight of his ex’s title. This is the attractive, sparkly, outgoing lady who swooped down and took his virginity when he was 27, dated him for six months, dumped him out of nowhere, and broke his coronary heart. She is the one different lady he’s ever been with, whereas I haven’t been with anybody however him. As a lot as I do know he loves me, our 4-year-old daughter, and the child we simply came upon I’m pregnant with, I’ve all the time felt insecure about how he nonetheless appears to place his ex on a pedestal and agonizes sometimes over dropping her. Unable to manage my curiosity, I skimmed the lengthy message she’d despatched him…

Get the newest from Prudie and our columnists in your inbox every weekday, plus particular bonus letters on Saturdays.