Wildlife images is an inherently contentious subject, and baiting is arguably prime of the checklist. I not too long ago wrote a semi-viral article a few photographer who chased an owl round a area and refused to cease, which has precipitated me to research my very own behaviour as a photographer.
Now, I’ll cease wanting calling myself a hardcore wildlife photographer, as a result of though I really like photographing wildlife, it’s not one thing I get to do recurrently. And certainly, most of the most memorable wildlife experiences I’ve had have been by means of my earlier function working as Deputy Editor of N-Photo: The Nikon Magazine.
Each issue we would run a feature called ‘The Apprentice’. This was a fly-on-the-wall account of a workshop where one lucky reader would get the chance to be tutored by a professional photographer and while we covered all genres, wildlife photography was a regular occurrence.
Leading workshops is a key source of income for many wildlife photographers, and they cater to photographers from all skill levels and all walks of life. However, you probably wouldn’t get many returning customers, if your workshops consisted of sitting in a river for six hours, in a bid to photograph a family of otters who may or may not turn up. Inevitably, some wildlife workshops (including some of those I covered for the magazine) involve baiting.
Now, in an ideal world, no photographer would bait. But we don’t live in an ideal world, and not all baiting is created equally. Baiting is anything – although typically food – used to lure an animal. Unwanted side effects can include dependency, overfeeding, behavioral changes, and the spread of disease. With all that in mind, it seems like a cut-and-shut case, baiting is bad. But not all baiting is created equally.
I’m never going to call baiting ethical, but in some cases, there’s an argument that it’s necessary. Of the few baited shoots I’ve been on, all were in conjunction with some kind of conservation effort. Specifically, organizations that were directly contributing to protecting, bolstering, or maintaining the numbers of endangered or once-endangered species.
The workshops I attended were for red kites, red squirrels, and ospreys. Conservation has allowed red kites to bounce back from near extinction in the UK, ospreys to recolonize following extinction in Britain, and red squirrels to maintain a few small strongholds, following decimation from the invasive grey squirrel.
The red kites were photographed at Gigrin Farm in Wales. This web site’s supplemental feeding was integral to the birds’ comeback from the Nineties, and opened to the general public to fund its meals supply, with the blessing of the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB). The ospreys have been photographed at a trout farm in Rutland Water, the guts of the osprey reintroduction challenge, whereby ospreys have been frequently raiding the farm searching for meals. Rather than internet every pond, the farm sought to work with the Rutland Osprey Project and now leaves one pond unnetted, in order to not prohibit this important meals supply solely.
And within the case of the purple squirrels, the hides, the place I photographed these little critters, is likely one of the few locations the place they nonetheless reside in England. They exist in the identical space because the hides and are supplied with the identical nuts that they feed on naturally. With numbers already low and the world uncovered to significantly harsh winters, the workshops present important supplementary feed for the colder months.
As I’ve hopefully illustrated, the topic of baiting isn’t fairly so simple as it first sounds. My personal private feeling is that baited wildlife images must be judged on a case-by-case foundation. But it’s one thing I believe all wildlife photographers ought to concentrate on. Technically, feeding backyard birds might be thought-about baiting, and whereas I’m not going to get into that right here, even that has sparked ongoing discussions as as to if or not the professionals outweigh the cons.
Ultimately, wildlife images is at all times going to be inherently controversial. Heck, we now dwell in a world of such data overload, you might pose the query: Do we actually want one other ethically captured {photograph} of a polar bear to know that this weak species’ habitat is in harmful decline? Probably not… And but, who would wish to deny the world of up-to-the-minute imagery of those magnificent creatures we must always all really feel privileged to share this planet with?
I doubt there’s a wildlife photographer on the planet who has at all times operated solely ethically. In truth, I’m unsure it’s doable immediately. The principal factor is that we maintain workshops, hides, reserves, and certainly ourselves to excessive requirements. Unnecessarily and clearly unethical baiting must be prevented in any respect prices, every part else must be left to your discretion.
And if you happen to’re any person who’s skilled a clearly unethical baited expertise previously, this text doesn’t exist to level the finger. It exists to make folks extra conscious of their influence as a wildlife photographer, and what they’ll fairly do to minimize.
Perhaps you agree with the above, maybe you’ve got exceedingly robust opinions you’d wish to share within the feedback part under. Believe me, I’d love to listen to your take. Just do not forget that it’s higher to interact in wholesome dialogue, that means, we will all be taught and develop as photographers.
You may also like…
If you are into wildlife images, take a look at the best cameras for wildlife photography and the best lenses for bird photography. Here are my 10 tips for wildlife photography from birds in flight to insect close-ups.