“One Night Only,” the newest romantic comedy from director Will Gluck (“Anyone but You”), builds itself round a premise so absurd that the questions it raises instantly threaten to overhaul the “rom-com” side of the movie. In the movie’s model of the United States, premarital intercourse is prohibited for 364 days of the yr and permitted solely on one designated evening, with nearly each single particular person within the nation taking part in a government-sanctioned night of sexual exercise. The idea holds apparent comedic and dramatic potential, however the movie finds itself way more all in favour of exploiting the premise primarily as a backdrop for the story to happen.
Luckily for “One Night Only,” crucial side of a profitable rom-com, two interesting leads with real chemistry, presents itself strongly. Callum Turner and Monica Barbaro’s charming performances present the movie with a robust emotional middle. Turner performs Owen, a good-natured New Yorker who runs a pizza store and is pressured to enterprise out alone on crucial evening of the yr after his longtime girlfriend decides to have intercourse with another person on the final minute. Barbaro brings an efficient mixture of confidence and down-to-earth power as Allie, a singer for commercials, additionally looking for a significant connection on exemption evening after earlier failed makes an attempt.
Gluck, a longtime rom-com director, additionally demonstrates a robust understanding of the style’s visible and tonal conventions. His depiction of New York is likely one of the higher trendy portrayals of the town that by no means sleeps, displaying a vibrant, lived-in high quality that contrasts the movie’s weird dystopian premise. There are additionally a number of enjoyable sequences, together with a scene through which Owen and Allie, every with totally different hookups, try to buy the final condom in a retailer at a particularly inflated worth.
The drawback is that the movie repeatedly gestures in direction of the darker implications of a fascist regime, then simply hand-waves a considerable rationalization for the way the world ended up this fashion. It is defined that the federal government displays residents’ sexual exercise via gadgets able to detecting modifications in dopamine ranges, with folks being arrested for participating in sexual exercise outdoors the designated evening. But any makes an attempt at fleshing out the world simply find yourself elevating much more questions. Would actions akin to sports activities or live shows not additionally set off the dopamine sensor? Why would corporations not mass-produce condoms for the exemption evening? Why would the overall inhabitants even be accepting of those legal guidelines? “One Night Only” needs the viewers to acknowledge its dystopian components, but it surely concurrently asks the viewers to not assume too severely about them.
The movie finds itself equally conflicted in its remedy of romantic-comedy conventions. Its characters brazenly acknowledge the cliches governing their relationship, virtually stating that the “universe” is making an attempt to pressure them collectively. Yet the movie in the end follows these conventions virtually precisely, so the self-awareness turns into much less of a subversion and extra of a tongue-in-cheek wink on the viewers.
The movie does make occasional worthwhile observations about how consumerism and trendy digital know-how have seeped their means into even essentially the most human actions of looking for a companion, with some enjoyable bits involving courting apps and tech-bro tradition.
Ultimately, “One Night Only” succeeds as a nice, sometimes humorous romantic comedy, largely as a result of Turner and Barbaro show an extremely enjoyable pair to observe on display screen. In phrases of addressing the high-concept premise, nevertheless, it’s much less profitable in its sharp critique of authoritarianism and primarily settles for standard romance as an alternative. Perhaps the one means for a studio romantic comedy to get greenlit in 2026 is to incorporate such a premise. The result’s a largely enjoyable and fascinating will-they-won’t-they so long as one doesn’t assume too onerous in regards to the unusual world the story takes place in.
3 Durex Condoms out of 5