The Price of Having Enjoyable

Humans are hardwired to get pleasure from playing. It offers a dopamine hit by triggering the mind’s reward system, a response strongly linked to the unpredictability of reward, not simply successful. Despite everybody realizing that “the house always wins,” the industrial on line casino gaming income for the state of Nevada grew to a report $15.8 billion in 2025. Or, nearer to GMO’s headquarters in Massachusetts, lottery gamers spend over $1,000 per individual yearly—greater than triple the nationwide common of simply over $300 per individual throughout 45 collaborating states.

Growth investing has a return distribution rather more akin to playing than worth investing, and most would agree that being a development investor is much more “fun” than being a price investor. Everybody loves the thought of investing within the subsequent Amazon or Nvidia. But we’d argue {that a} sturdy purpose to think about worth investing is that, whereas it’s doubtlessly much less thrilling, your anticipated return is greater.

Stack the percentages in your favor

To start with, the percentages are skewed in your favor: over five-year horizons, 60% of worth shares (Exhibit 1, inexperienced bars) outperform the market. At the extremes, a small variety of worth shares do go bankrupt (Exhibit 1, far-left inexperienced bar), whereas just a few ship really extraordinary returns (Exhibit 1, far-right inexperienced bars, which present shares that elevated by at the very least 10x).

---

EXHIBIT 1: U.S. STOCKS ARE LOTTERY-LIKE

Average 5-year relative return distribution of U.S. worth and U.S. development shares

As of 9/30/2025 | Source: Bloomberg, Compustat, Worldscope, MSCI, GMO

---

Growth shares (Exhibit 1, pink bars) supply a really totally different return distribution, with maybe essentially the most noticeable distinction being that over twice as many development shares go on to change into 10-baggers. But chasing these success tales has an disagreeable draw back–one that’s typically ignored as inconvenient shares merely vanish from development portfolios and are by no means talked about once more. The proportion of development shares that go bankrupt is over 50% greater than that of worth shares (Exhibit 1, far-left pink bar), whereas fewer than 40% of development shares have outperformed the market over five-year time frames.

What about valuation?

Given that the worth paid for any asset is an important determinant of potential return, at GMO we consider that every one traders ought to be valuation-aware traders, not simply dyed-in-the-wool development or worth traders. Although worth shares have, on common, delivered higher returns than development shares, beginning valuations may doubtlessly skew the stability towards development shares now and again. For simply over a decade, beginning in 2005, slender valuation spreads between worth and development shares instructed a poor atmosphere for worth within the U.S.


¹
Today, nonetheless, valuation spreads are extraordinarily large. With all the excitement across the transformative potential of synthetic intelligence, traders’ willingness to pay as much as chase the lottery-like payoff of development shares is at historic extremes, making it a very compelling time to favor worth shares. 

Exhibit 2 exhibits the relative valuation for U.S. worth shares in comparison with U.S. development shares, normalized in order that 1.0 represents the median. Today, worth shares are buying and selling at an approximate 35% low cost to their typical relative valuation, a tenth percentile commentary vs. historical past. Value must beat development by nearly 55% simply to return to traditionally regular relative valuations.

---

EXHIBIT 2: VALUE IS EXTREMELY CHEAP

As of two/28/2026 | Source: GMO
Stock valuations are calculated on a mix of Price/Sales, Price/Gross Profit, and Price/Economic Book.

---

Even if this abnormally large valuation unfold doesn’t slender instantly, we consider worth can nonetheless outperform attributable to what we name the rebalancing impact. Value advantages as some development corporations disappoint and change into cheaper, getting into the worth index. Value additionally advantages as some worth corporations shock on the upside and get repriced into the expansion index. This impact is especially pronounced when valuation spreads are large because the valuation change related to a transfer from worth to development or development to worth is massive. (In the context of an energetic technique, corresponding to our lengthy worth/quick development Equity Dislocation Strategy, this rebalancing impact is demonstrated as sturdy safety choice. From the top of 2022 by means of the top of February 2026, safety choice has helped the Equity Dislocation Strategy ship a web return of 6.3% each year, regardless of MSCI ACWI Growth beating MSCI ACWI Value by some 8% each year over the identical interval.) 

How are you able to finest monetize this dislocation?

• Equity Dislocation seeks to immediately revenue by going lengthy the most cost effective worth shares and quick the most costly development shares in a market-neutral portfolio.
• Dial into deep worth by means of long-only fairness portfolios, like U.S. and International Opportunistic Value, which goal the most cost effective cohort of shares.

 

Download article >