Man United Hold or Dump: Pogba and Fred to go? De Gea to maneuver on mortgage?

This web page was created programmatically, to learn the article in its unique location you’ll be able to go to the hyperlink bellow:
and if you wish to take away this text from our web site please contact us

Manchester United loved their joint-best league putting since Sir Alex Ferguson retired as supervisor in 2013, with Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s crew ending second within the Premier League and likewise having an opportunity to win the Europa League in opposition to Villarreal.

Regardless of progress being made on the pitch at Previous Trafford, United nonetheless completed 12 factors behind champions Manchester City. A gaggle-stage exit from the Champions League and failure to make it to a home cup last underline the continuing points that Solskjaer wants to deal with.

Stream ESPN FC Daily on ESPN+ (U.S. only)
– Ogden: De Gea or Henderson? Man United’s No. 1 spot must be settled

Having cleared out plenty of underperforming excessive earners in current summers, together with Romelu Lukaku, Alexis Sanchez and Chris Smalling, United now have a youthful, leaner squad.

However there may be nonetheless work to be accomplished earlier than they are often considered challengers for Premier League and Champions League success once more. With that in thoughts, we have now carried out a player-by-player evaluation, trying to carry readability to United’s squad-strengthening choices. The place you see a easy “Keep,” you’ll be able to assume we agreed and there wasn’t a lot to speak about. In any other case, we weighed in with our feedback.

It is not nearly efficiency, both. It is about age, wages, character and contract size (we went with Transfermarkt for contract expiry dates for consistency). And there will likely be shifting components, too: departures or arrivals that trigger chain reactions, generally sudden.

Be aware: A number of United gamers have contracts that embrace the choice of an additional yr on expiry. For consistency, all contracts under relate to the first yr of expiration.

Soar to: Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards | Overall assessment


David de Gea (30 years previous, contract expires in 2023)

OGDEN: De Gea has been in decline for the reason that 2018 World Cup and has made too many expensive errors to be trusted as United’s No. 1. He’s nonetheless able to unimaginable saves, however they do not outweigh the errors, so United want to dump. Together with his big wages (over £300,000-a-week) and speak to scenario, a mortgage is the more than likely possibility this summer season as discovering a membership to signal him completely will likely be just about unimaginable as a result of monetary influence of the pandemic, so they should wait till issues enhance earlier than shifting him on.

DAWSON: He’s on large wages, however Henderson has taken his place, so there isn’t a sense or worth in holding him to take a seat on the bench.

Verdict: Dump or mortgage (estimated price for everlasting deal: £20m)

Dean Henderson (24, 2025)

DAWSON: No want to increase his contract, however United should signal a back-up keeper to problem him correctly subsequent season and guarantee complacency does not set in.

OGDEN: He seems to be successful his battle with De Gea to be United’s No. 1 however he has an extended contract already. Henderson is just not the completed article by any means, so see how he progresses earlier than contemplating a brand new deal.

Verdict: Hold

Sergio Romero (34, 2021)

DAWSON: Out of contract in the summertime and hasn’t performed all season, so let him go.

OGDEN: Ought to have been allowed to depart final summer season when United had affords, however poor decision-making noticed them maintain out for too excessive a price and ended up having to pay a non-playing keeper 12 months of wages.

Verdict: Dump (Finish of contract — free switch)

Lee Grant (38, 2021)

DAWSON: His enjoying contract is up and he might transfer onto the teaching employees.

Verdict: Dump (Finish of contract — free switch)


Aaron Wan-Bissaka (23, 2024)

OGDEN: He nonetheless must work on his sport, particularly his distribution and focus, however he’s clearly United’s first-choice right-back. If he continues his improvement, prolong his contract in 12 months’ time.

DAWSON: Hold him, clearly, however no have to renew his contract simply but.

Verdict: Hold

Brandon Williams (20, 2024)

DAWSON: He wants video games, so a mortgage transfer can be the most suitable choice for him subsequent season.

Verdict: Hold (however ship on mortgage)

Harry Maguire (28, 2025)

OGDEN: His contract expires when he’s 32, so United are coated for the long run with their captain. However his current harm has highlighted his significance to the crew, so he might must be rewarded with a brand new deal in a yr’s time.

Verdict: Hold

Victor Lindelof (26, 2024)

OGDEN: He was fortunate to get a four-year deal in 2020 after an unimpressive first three years at United and his presence within the crew is all the way down to the dearth of appropriate options within the squad. In a really perfect world, you’d let him go and reinvest in a greater defender however, realistically, Lindelof is the least-worst choice to associate Maguire, so he’ll keep.

DAWSON: United gave him an extended contract final yr after they did not have to, to allow them to’t do something however preserve him.

Verdict: Hold

Eric Bailly (27, 2024)

DAWSON: He has simply signed a brand new contract, so he stays. However wants to remain match now.

OGDEN: I like Bailly. He has tempo and tenacity, however he’s additionally harm inclined and may make some inexplicable selections on the pitch. His new deal is sensible, but in addition suggests United will not be available in the market for a much-needed new centre-back this summer season.

Verdict: Hold

Phil Jones (29, 2023)

DAWSON: Transfer him on, in the event you can.

OGDEN: He hasn’t performed since January 2020, however nonetheless has two years, plus the choice of one other 12 months, on his contract. Jones has been a great servant for 10 years and unfortunate with accidents, however United ought to lower their losses and let him go on a free as a result of it is unimaginable to think about any membership paying a price for him.

Verdict: Dump — Launch (estimated price for everlasting deal: £5m)

Axel Tuanzebe (23, 2022)

DAWSON: Powerful one. He wants video games, however you’ll be able to’t mortgage him out within the last yr of his contract. United ought to take a danger and provides him the prospect to earn a brand new contract. If he does not, attempt to transfer him on in January.

OGDEN: Tuanzebe is just not a child anymore. If he hasn’t made it but, he by no means will.

Verdict: Cut up Hold and assess / Dump (estimated price: £12m)

Luke Shaw (25, 2023)

OGDEN: If any participant has earned a brand new contract this season, it’s Shaw. He has responded effectively to the signing of Alex Telles and has been one of the best left-back within the Premier League for the previous 12 months.

DAWSON: Begin speaking over a brand new deal.

Verdict: Hold and prolong

Alex Telles (28, 2024)

DAWSON: Good competitors for Shaw.

Verdict: Hold

Diogo Dalot (22, 2023)

OGDEN: United’s drawback lately has been giving too many probabilities (and new contracts) to gamers who clearly aren’t adequate. Dalot is not adequate, so transfer him on.

DAWSON: He is spent the yr on mortgage at AC Milan and has impressed coach Stefano Pioli, so carry him again as his versatility means he can cowl for each full-back positions. That will allow Williams to exit on mortgage.

Verdict: Cut up Dump / Hold (estimated price: £12m)



Mark Ogden contemplates Paul Pogba’s greatest place for Man United as questions surrounding his future proceed.


Nemanja Matic (32, 2023)

DAWSON: United are caught with him, having handed him a brand new contract he hadn’t earned. They will not have the ability to get a good price for him, in order that they’ll preserve him.

OGDEN: I believe his expertise is vital, particularly alongside Scott McTominay. He is not significantly cellular today, however he is a helpful participant to have within the squad.

Verdict: Hold

Fred (28, 2023)

OGDEN: I would attempt to transfer him on, as a result of his passing is poor, he is not a very good tackler and does not rating targets. However he has performed nearly 50 video games this season, so Solskjaer should see one thing in him. For those who may get £20m and use the cash for a greater participant, I would do it.

DAWSON: Do not give him a brand new deal; let him go.

Verdict: Dump (estimated price: £20m)

Paul Pogba (28, 2022)

DAWSON: Attempt to prolong his contract, but when they cannot then transfer him on in the summertime to get some switch price. In the meanwhile, no membership appears to have the type of cash that United need.

OGDEN: United must be imaginative with Pogba. With no apparent vacation spot and neither celebration significantly eager on the concept of a brand new contract, United ought to look to make use of him in a swap deal. Provide him to Juventus in alternate for Cristiano Ronaldo; or attempt to get Real Madrid to supply up Casemiro, Toni Kroos or Raphael Varane. However do not give him a brand new contract.

Verdict: Cut up Prolong / Dump (estimated price: £60m)

Scott McTominay (24, 2025)

OGDEN: He brings good power to the crew and may nonetheless develop his passing sport.

Verdict: Hold

Donny van de Beek (24, 2025)

DAWSON: Persevere with him and resolve on what to do in a yr if he hasn’t impressed.

OGDEN: Solskjaer clearly does not fee him, so why waste everybody’s time by prolonging the scenario for an additional yr? United will make a loss, having signed him for £35m final summer season, however the followers have already beginning to name him “Donny van de Bench,” in order that tells you the influence he has made at Previous Trafford.

Verdict: Cut up Hold / Dump (estimated price: £20m)

Juan Mata (33, 2021)

DAWSON: United have an possibility to increase his contract for a yr, but it surely’s time for him to go.

OGDEN: Mata has been a mannequin skilled in his seven years at United — and so they have been a tricky seven years for the membership — however he ought to now transfer on and luxuriate in some enjoying time elsewhere.

Verdict: Dump

Bruno Fernandes (26, 2025)

OGDEN: Give him a brand new contract. Neglect concerning the 4 years he has to run on his current deal, Fernandes has carried United since arriving from Sporting CP in January 2020, so they need to reward him by making him the best-paid participant on the membership.

DAWSON: I agree. Give him a pay rise and do every thing to point out how vital he’s.

Verdict: Hold and prolong

Jesse Lingard (28, 2023)

DAWSON: He has accomplished sufficient on mortgage at West Ham to earn a brand new deal, but it surely’s unlikely he’ll need to come again as cowl for Fernandes.

OGDEN: A transfer would go well with United and Lingard. He must play and United can get a switch price within the area of £25m on the again of his West Ham performances. Solskjaer displayed a scarcity of religion in Lingard by hardly ever utilizing him previous to his mortgage transfer, so it does not replicate effectively on the supervisor that the midfielder has accomplished so effectively elsewhere.

Verdict: Dump (estimated price: £25m)

Andreas Pereira (25, 2023)

OGDEN: One other instance of United missing ruthlessness with regards to offloading gamers who aren’t adequate. Pereira ought to have been moved on a minimum of two years in the past.

DAWSON: He is been on mortgage at Lazio all season and has accomplished little to warrant a return to United, so do away with him in the event you can.

Verdict: Dump (estimated price: £10m)

James Garner (20, 2022)

DAWSON: He has accomplished effectively on mortgage at Nottingham Forest, so prolong his contract and mortgage him out once more subsequent season.

Verdict: Hold and prolong



Steve Nicol feels Manchester United’s behavior of falling behind in video games may hang-out them in larger matches if not solved.


Marcus Rashford (23, 2023)

DAWSON: United want to begin speaking a few new deal, as a result of they’re coming into the ultimate two years of his contract. If they do not, they may should let him go subsequent summer season, particularly if the crew fails to point out indicators they’ll win a giant trophy.

OGDEN: You’ll be able to sense bother forward with Rashford. He’ll need to see United stepping as much as problem for the highest honours, however, equally, he must take his personal sport to a different degree by changing into extra constant. If he does not signal a brand new contract. United could have a giant drawback subsequent summer season.

Verdict: Hold and prolong

Daniel James (23, 2024)

OGDEN: His massive asset is his tempo, however opponents have labored out how you can cope with that now, so he affords little or no to United past sincere endeavour. And that is not sufficient for a crew with aspirations of successful massive trophies.

DAWSON: Hold, however do not prolong.

Verdict: Cut up Hold / Dump (estimated price: £20m)

Mason Greenwood (19, 2025)

DAWSON: Among the best younger gamers round. He signed a brand new deal this season, so no want to increase once more simply but.

Verdict: Hold

Amad Diallo (18, 2025)

DAWSON: He must play, however he is not able to be concerned on a constant foundation at United so ought to go on mortgage.

Verdict: Hold and mortgage

Anthony Martial (25, 2024)

DAWSON: United ought to be open to affords as a result of he’s too inconsistent, however they’re prone to preserve him.

OGDEN: After six years at united, he has a strike fee of a objective each 3.Three video games, which is not sufficient for a participant of his expertise. However the necessity to offload different gamers ensures that he’s prone to survive by default for an additional yr.

Verdict: Hold

Edinson Cavani (34, 2022)

OGDEN: After nearly becoming a member of Boca Juniors, he prolonged his contract for an additional 12 months. The Uruguay worldwide has been a vital addition to the squad with over 15 targets this season and provides United time to discover a youthful, long-term answer to their centre-forward search.

Verdict: Hold

Tahith Chong (21, 2022)

DAWSON: Not adequate and his kind at Club Brugge on mortgage this season hasn’t urged he has a future at United.

Verdict: Dump (estimated price: £4m)

Facundo Pellistri (19 2025)

OGDEN: Solely simply signed and one for the longer term. Has been on mortgage at Alaves in Spain.

Verdict: Hold


United have proven they’ve a robust first crew this season, however they proceed to lack depth and high quality past their beginning XI. The issue they’ve is that lots of these gamers who fall in need of the required requirements must keep this summer season as a result of no membership can realistically do away with 10 squad members and exchange them multi functional window.

With the switch market prone to be hit arduous by the monetary influence of the COVID-19 pandemic, will probably be robust to seek out golf equipment who can signal the likes of De Gea, Fred, Van de Beek, Pogba, Lindelof, James and Martial. But when a deal for Pogba is struck within the area of £80m, United may reap the benefits of the actual fact some gamers will likely be obtainable for a knock-down price.

United stay within the hunt for Borussia Dortmund‘s Jadon Sancho, who will value a minimum of £80m to signal, however a transfer for the England winger will eat up the membership’s summer season finances.

If they’re to go additional and signal a centre-forward similar to Tottenham’s Harry Kane or Dortmund’s Erling Haaland (each of whom would command a price of over £120m), they must transfer on from Pogba and De Gea to boost funds and get their mixed £600,000-a-week off the wage invoice. That will likely be simpler stated than accomplished, so count on one other irritating summer season of switch dealings at Previous Trafford.

This web page was created programmatically, to learn the article in its unique location you’ll be able to go to the hyperlink bellow:
and if you wish to take away this text from our web site please contact us

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

10 − seven =