Solving a potato origin thriller with an unlikely hybrid union : Short Wave : NPR

SPEAKER: You’re listening to Short Wave from NPR.

BERLY MCCOY: Hey, Short Wavers, producer Berly McCoy within the host chair right now with a biology thriller that I discovered about from Katherine Wu. She’s a employees author for The Atlantic masking science. And a pair years in the past, she was speaking to a scientist as a part of her current kick reporting on frogs.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

KATHERINE WU: As one does. And she was speaking to me about hybrids.

[END PLAYBACK]

MCCOY: Hybrids, the results of members of two totally different species mating– on this case, two totally different species of frogs.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

WU: It simply struck me as so weird that there can be a state of affairs wherein one frog was in search of out a mate of one other species. It made zero sense. It had made zero sense to the researcher on the time she found it. I mainly needed to know extra.

[END PLAYBACK]

MCCOY: In her reporting, Katie discovered that feminine plains spadefoot toads that reside within the North American desert actively select to mate with males exterior of their species when the swimming pools they’re in are at greater threat of drying up. They do that as a result of it seems the tadpoles from that unlikely union mature just a bit bit quicker, giving them a greater alternative to hop away as adults earlier than the swimming pools dry up, which might be a mushy demise in the event you’re a not-quite-ripe tadpole. But there is a catch.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

WU: The offspring are much less fertile. So the males are completely sterile, and the females do not produce as many eggs.

[END PLAYBACK]

MCCOY: Because the health of animals throughout nature is usually subpar, like these froggy fertility points or different well being issues, biologists have lengthy considered interspecies mating as–

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

WU: A catastrophe more often than not. Think of the sterile hinnies and mules that come out of horse-donkey unions. You consider form of sad-looking ligers that come out of lion-tiger unions in zoos. And this was actually the predominant considering for many years and many years and many years.

[END PLAYBACK]

MCCOY: That is, till lately.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

WU: There are these estimates which might be most likely underestimates at this level, that one thing like 10% of animal species and 25% of plant species do often mate exterior of their very own species. And it is not a complete catastrophe. It cannot be. Otherwise, that would not persist over time.

[END PLAYBACK]

MCCOY: Scientists are discovering that typically, hybrids can kind model new traits.

[AUDIO PLAYBACK]

WU: Neither of its dad and mom might kind something that even appeared like a potato. And by some means, their offspring did.

[END PLAYBACK]

MCCOY: Today on the present, the ingenuity of hybrids– we transfer from frogs to how scientists resolved the mysterious origins of a beloved staple crop, the potato, and the way this and different hybrid tales are reshaping scientists’ notions of them. You’re listening to Short Wave, the science podcast from NPR.

[INTRIGUING MUSIC]

MCCOY: OK, Katie. Let’s begin with the place potatoes come from, which is from two very previous, distinct species of crops. Do you realize what these two crops appeared like?

WU: So I couldn’t responsibly describe for you what two roughly 9-million-old crops appeared like. But we are able to kind of guess as a result of each of their descendants are round right now. So one among them was a tomato plant. We all can form of image a tomato plant, like good, stunning, reddish form of fruits on a leafy inexperienced plant. And the opposite one, in the event you’ve ever seen the highest half of a potato plant above floor, it appeared largely like that– leafy, inexperienced, some good flowers on high.

MCCOY: OK. So these are the 2 dad and mom of the– what resulted within the potato. And I did not understand that this was, like, a misplaced love story that nobody actually knew the reply to. But apparently, it stumped scientists for a very long time?

WU: Yeah. And a bunch of them put it to me this manner. You know, simply with all due respect to potatoes, their household tree is that this whole and full mess.

MCCOY: I can relate, really. I feel lots of people can.

WU: Yeah. Potatoes are messy, numerous household drama. But mainly, they know that there is greater than 100 potato species round right now. But after they attempt to hint these again in time and work out the place did all of them come from, what was kind of the inciting occasion that spawned this huge range of species, they find yourself getting stumped. You know, potato genomes are actually difficult. And to allow them to’t simply piece it collectively actually simply, like they’ll for another plant teams. But they’d a pair concepts. So potatoes are inside this large group known as the nightshades, which really does embody, you realize, the tomato, one among its dad and mom, we now know.

MCCOY: Mm-hmm. This is sensible as a gardener.

WU: Yeah. But additionally, eggplants and peppers– this can be a very scrumptious, very productive household. [LAUGHS] But they could not work out precisely the place potatoes had come from. The two predominant candidates had been really tomato and etuberosum, which is the opposite mum or dad within the story. But scientists had been mainly all the time contemplating one or the opposite, tomato or etuberosum. For the reply to now be each is a little bit bit mind-blowing since you do not anticipate it to be this love story that yields a hybrid that turns into the potato. You determine, oh, it is most carefully associated to the tomato. No, it is largely associated to etuberosum. It was a workforce tomato or workforce etuberosum story. Team each was not on the desk.

MCCOY: OK. And so is it that they thought that the potato a part of the plant advanced both when it was within the lineage of, like, the tomato plant or this etuberosum and in some unspecified time in the future the one with the potato crossed and that is how, like, their genes intertwined? But they by no means thought that it was this hybridization occasion, this coming collectively of two separate species that really was the factor that created what would grow to be the potato.

WU: Right. So what was so complicated and irritating about piecing collectively this origin story was, in the event you appeared on the potato genome, elements of it appeared just like the tomato genome and elements of it appeared just like the etuberosum genome. And so it was like, nicely, OK, so which did it come from? Was it that it advanced from a tomato plant that someplace down the road simply invented the potato? And then perhaps, you realize, some historic potato combined with etuberosum, and that is how etuberosum stuff acquired within the potato genome. Or was it the entire inverse? You know, it descended from etuberosum, then combined with a tomato plant [INAUDIBLE]. Those are actually the 2 predominant prospects that folks had been contemplating. They did not discover that. All the species they checked out had roughly the identical mixture of tomato and etuberosum as one another. Like, all of them appeared like the identical medley, which implies that there was most likely only one occasion that introduced the tomato and etuberosum genomes collectively, which suggests hybridization. That’s form of the one choice whenever you see the info that they noticed. So there was one occasion. The two genomes combined. And that spawned, you realize, an early potato. And that early potato led to the 100-plus species we see right now. It wasn’t that, you realize, a tomato made a potato after which bizarre stuff occurred afterward. It was that these two crops got here collectively initially, and the potato was born, and nobody ever appeared again.

MCCOY: And so this large shock, this hybridization occasion, led to what we all know and love because the potato. I believe we additionally do not actually know a lot about what that appeared like. But I need to ask only for enjoyable, what do you suppose it appeared like– like a tomato, however within the floor?

WU: So I don’t know what the primary potato plant appeared like. But it most likely was not a tomato rising underground, simply, like, given the best way that crops produce totally different organs. Like, tomatoes come out of the flowering elements of the plant, proper? And so that’s above floor. When we’re speaking a couple of potato, that’s, like, by definition, an underground storage organ. It’s a tuber. It has to form of come out of, like, the underground system the place a bunch of vitamins are being saved. I imply, a potato is mainly an enormous nutrient storage organ. And so that you’re by no means going to get a potato– you are by no means going to get a correct potato rising on the above-ground portion of a plant. And you are by no means going to get a correct tomato rising on the below-ground portion of a plant.

MCCOY: Can uncovering this potato thriller assist us with the spuds of right now? Like, it looks like actually attention-grabbing science. But can it inform how we’re rising meals now?

WU: I feel the reply for proper now’s perhaps, query mark, most likely, query mark. There’s not a set-in-stone plan to, you realize, repair every little thing that’s flawed with potatoes right now. But the potatoes we eat, they do have points. They are prone to illness. And their genomes are form of a ache to work with. So cultivated potatoes, the potatoes we eat, they’ve 4 copies of each chromosome. And that is an actual ache for breeders. Just belief me on this one. It is a large ache for breeders. And so if they’ll work out a solution to simply use this data to enhance the potato genome, make it simpler to work with, perhaps that may very well be actually attention-grabbing. One kind of out of the field concept that a few of the scientists who labored on this venture are taking part in with are, you realize, utilizing this data to assist tomato crops make underground tubers, so making their very own potatoes.

MCCOY: What?

WU: They do not know if that is fully potential. And it would most likely be extraordinarily tough whether it is potential in any respect. But, you realize, it may very well be the case that sometime you are consuming fries and ketchup and so they got here from primarily the identical plant.

MCCOY: Oh my gosh, that may be so superb.

WU: I’ll say, scientists have form of cheated their solution to that answer earlier than. You know, the tomato and potato crops are nonetheless carefully associated sufficient you could graft them on to one another. So you can– you realize, it is like a Franken-plant, proper? That’s not the identical as–

MCCOY: You can mash them collectively and so they keep alive and produce each issues?

WU: Yeah. [LAUGHS] It’s not fairly the identical as coaxing a tomato, like, with genetic manipulation to make its personal potatoes. But, you realize, it is a little bit bit extra like organ donation whenever you splice the 2 together– or a human centipede, whichever metaphor you favor right here.

MCCOY: Oh my goodness.

WU: One is a little bit grosser than the opposite.

MCCOY: Yes. I would like one among these crops now. So this instance of a hybrid– and just like the frogs that we talked about earlier– what do they inform scientists about how helpful hybrids are?

WU: I feel these examples and a bunch of others which have emerged in current many years are actually serving to to rewrite the evolutionary story on hybrids. It continues to be completely the case that more often than not, when a species mates with one other organism exterior its personal species, it is not going to work. They most likely will not have profitable offspring to start with. But typically it does work. Sometimes these offspring do come to be. Sometimes these offspring can reproduce. And typically these offspring are so totally different in attention-grabbing and thrilling methods from their dad and mom that they are in a position to do issues that neither of their dad and mom might. And that may result in actually unimaginable occasions, like making numerous new species, placing out into new environments, even probably human evolution. It looks like there’s hybridization in our personal evolutionary historical past. So it may be a extremely highly effective evolutionary drive that may drive evolutionary innovation in a approach that simply mating inside your personal species cannot.

[CONTEMPLATIVE MUSIC]

MCCOY: Katherine Wu is a science journalist at The Atlantic. See our present notes for each of her articles on hybrids. Thank you a lot, Katie.

WU: Always good to be right here.

MCCOY: This episode was produced by me, Berly McCoy, and edited by our showrunner, Rebecca Ramirez. Tyler Jones checked the info, and Robert Rodriguez was the audio engineer. Beth Donovan is our Senior Director, and Collin Campbell is our Senior Vice President of Podcasting Strategy. I’m Berly McCoy. Thanks for listening to Short Wave from NPR.

[CONTEMPLATIVE MUSIC]

Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.

Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could fluctuate. Transcript textual content could also be revised to right errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.