Does weight regain occur sooner after stopping weight reduction treatment, than after stopping a life-style intervention?

The media has been going loopy this previous week over a current article suggesting that weight regain is quicker after stopping weight reduction drugs than after stopping a life-style intervention. Let’s discuss in regards to the information – then, let’s discuss my largest concern right here – why we’re discussing regain after remedy within the first place??

The research, published within the British Medical Journal, checked out weight regain after stopping remedy in research of weight administration drugs, in comparison with research of life-style administration packages. They discovered that weight regain after stopping weight administration drugs was about 0.4kg (just below 1lb) per 30 days. This price of weight regain was about 0.3kg (0.7lb) per 30 days sooner than weight regain after stopping a life-style program, unbiased of how a lot weight was misplaced with remedy. The weight regain was projected to return to baseline (earlier than weight reduction treatment was began) at about 1.7 years, and the cardiovascular threat issue advantages (eg blood sugars, blood strain) had been projected to return to pre-treatment ranges inside 1.4 years after stopping treatment.

I’ve quite a lot of issues about this research. First of all, non randomized and observational research had been included. This implies that the individuals within the treatment vs life-style remedies weren’t the identical. Some individuals have extra success with life-style change than others, and those that take treatment could have extra problem with life-style change than those that don’t. Secondly, whereas the typical research period was 39 weeks, research of simply 8 weeks (with 4 weeks submit remedy observe up) had been eligible for inclusion within the evaluation. This is method too brief to say something significant about weight administration with any intervention.

My BIGGEST drawback with this research is that it utterly ignores the KEY POINT – weight administration methods are supposed to be long run, and aren’t supposed to be stopped. I can’t think about an analogous research on, say, remedy of hypertension. How quick does blood strain bounce again up after stopping blood strain treatment, vs after stopping a low salt weight loss plan? Sounds ridiculous, doesn’t it. That’s as a result of we wouldn’t cease treating the hypertension – we might proceed remedy long run if it was working to manage the blood strain.

Similarly, in our Obesity Canada 2025 Pharmacotherapy Clinical Practice Guideline (disclosure, I’m the lead creator), we have now a particular evidence-based advice to make use of weight administration treatment long run, when efficient, to keep away from weight regain and regression of well being advantages. Same goes for life-style interventions.

All of that being mentioned, the unlucky actuality is that in actual life, many individuals find yourself stopping weight administration treatment. This is commonly on account of value, lack of insurance coverage, or shortages (in prior years). Sometimes it’s as a result of an individual didn’t tolerate the treatment properly. Sometimes it’s as a result of the time wasn’t taken with the well being care skilled earlier than beginning remedy to assist the individual perceive the biology of weight, and that we aren’t curing weight problems, however controlling it, with treatment.

The reply to this conundrum is to not scare individuals away from weight administration treatment as a result of they might regain weight sooner after stopping remedy. Instead, we have to empower individuals to grasp, earlier than beginning the remedy, that any weight problems remedy is meant to be long run. We have to develop drugs which can be higher tolerated than the presently accessible GLP1 drugs, and there are many trials of recent drugs underway to deal with this. We have to discover methods to make treatment cheaper and extra accessible. With the essential and wide-ranging well being advantages of newer weight problems drugs, insurance coverage packages (private and non-private) should be extra engaged in supporting the price of remedy. With new treaments like oral (in a capsule) GLP1 treatment and generics coming into some markets this yr, I’m optimistic that extra individuals will have the ability to afford to take remedy longterm. Finally, authors level out that individuals who had been in life-style change trials could have discovered extra sensible coping expertise to assist wholesome life over the long run. Oftentimes, individuals prescribed weight reduction treatment don’t get life-style assist, and giving this assist by means of a complete program is essential to optimize success.

Subscribe to my weblog! (higher proper)

Follow me on X/twitter @drsuepedersen !

Share this weblog submit utilizing your favourite social media hyperlink beneath!

www.drsue.ca © 2026