Why industry-standard labels for AI in music might change how we pay attention

Earlier this 12 months, a band referred to as The Velvet Sundown racked up a whole lot of 1000’s of streams on Spotify with retro-pop tracks, generating a million monthly listeners on Spotify.

But the band wasn’t actual. Every music, picture, and even its back story, had been generated by someone using generative AI.

For some, it was a intelligent experiment. For others, it revealed a troubling lack of transparency in music creation, despite the fact that the band’s Spotify descriptor was later updated to acknowledge it’s composed with AI.

In September 2025, Spotify introduced it’s “helping develop and will support the new industry standard for AI disclosures in music credits developed through DDEX.” DDEX is a not-for-profit membership organization targeted on the creation of digital music worth chain requirements.

The firm additionally says it’s focusing work on improved enforcement of impersonation violations and a brand new spam-filtering system, and that updates are “the latest in a series of changes we’re making to support a more trustworthy music ecosystem for artists, for rights-holders and for listeners.”

As AI turns into extra embedded in music creation, the problem is balancing its respectable artistic use with the moral and financial pressures it introduces. Disclosure is important not only for accountability, however to offer listeners clear and user-friendly selections within the artists they help.

A patchwork of insurance policies

The music {industry}’s response to AI has to date been a mixture of advert hoc enforcement as platforms grapple with how one can handle emerging uses and expectations of AI in music.

Apple Music took goal at impersonation when it pulled the viral observe “Heart on My Sleeve” featuring AI-cloned vocals of Drake and The Weeknd. The elimination was prompted by a copyright criticism reflecting considerations over misuse of artists’ likeness and voice.

The indie-facing music promotion platform SubmitHub has launched measures to combate AI-generated spam. Artists should declare if AI performed “a major role” in a observe. The platform additionally has an “AI Song Checker” so playlist curators can scan recordsdata to detect AI use.

Spotify’s announcement provides one other dimension to those efforts. By specializing in disclosure, it acknowledges that artists use AI in many various methods throughout music creation and manufacturing. Rather than banning these practices, it opens the door to an AI labelling system that makes them extra clear.

Labelling artistic content material

Content labelling has lengthy been used to assist audiences make knowledgeable selections about their media consumption. Movies, TV and music include parental advisories, for instance.

Digital music recordsdata additionally embody embedded information tags called metadata, which embody particulars like style, tempo and contributing artists that platforms use to categorize songs, calculate royalty funds and to recommend new songs to listeners.

Canada has relied on labelling for many years to strengthen its home music {industry}. The MAPL system requires radio stations to play a minimal proportion of Canadian music, utilizing a set of standards to find out whether a song qualifies as Canadian content based mostly on music, artist, manufacturing and lyrics.

Read extra:
How will we outline Canadian content material? Debates will form how creatives make a dwelling

As more algorithmically generated AI music appears on streaming platforms, an AI disclosure label would give listeners a method to uncover music that matches their preferences, whether or not they’re interested by AI collaboration or drawn to extra conventional human-crafted approaches.

What might AI music labels deal with?

A disclosure normal will make AI music labelling doable. The subsequent step is cultural: deciding how a lot data needs to be shared with listeners, and in what type.

According to Spotify, artists and rights-holders shall be requested to specify the place and the way AI contributed to a observe. For instance, whether or not it was used for vocals, instrumentation or post-production work equivalent to mixing or mastering.

For artists, these particulars higher replicate how AI instruments match into a protracted custom of artistic use of recent applied sciences. After all, the synthesizer, drum machines and samplers — even the electrical guitar — have been all as soon as controversial.

But AI disclosure shouldn’t give streaming platforms a free move to flood catalogues with algorithmically generated content material. The level also needs to be to supply data to listeners to assist them make extra knowledgeable selections about what sort of music they wish to help.

Information about AI use needs to be simple to see and rapidly discover. But on Spotify’s Velvet Sundown profile, for instance, that is doubtful: listeners need to dig down to truly learn the band’s descriptor.

Read extra:
The triumph of vinyl: Vintage is again as LP gross sales proceed to skyrocket

AI and inventive tensions in music

AI in music raises urgent points, together with round labour and compensation, {industry} energy dynamics, in addition to licensing and rights.

One examine commissioned by the International Confederation of Societies of Authors and Composers has stated that Gen AI outputs could put 24 per cent of music creators’ revenues at risk by 2028, at a time when many musician careers are already weak to excessive prices of dwelling and an unpredictable and unstable streaming music economy.

The hottest AI music platforms are managed by main tech corporations. Will AI further concentrate creative power, or are there instruments that may minimize manufacturing prices and change into extensively utilized by unbiased artists? Will artists be compensated if their labels are involved in deals for artists’ music to train AI platforms?

The cultural notion round musicians having their music prepare AI platforms or in utilizing AI instruments in music manufacturing can also be a website of artistic rigidity.

Read extra:
AI could make up songs now, however who owns the copyright? The reply is difficult

Enabling listener alternative

Turning a disclosure normal into one thing seen — equivalent to an intuitive label or icon that enables customers to go deeper to point out how AI was used — would let listeners see at a look how human and algorithmic contributions mix in a observe.

Embedded within the digital music file, it might additionally assist followers and humanities organizations uncover and help music based mostly on the sort of creativity behind it.

Ultimately, it’s about giving listeners a alternative. A transparent, well-designed labelling system might assist audiences perceive the numerous methods AI now shapes music, from delicate manufacturing instruments to totally artificial vocals.

Need for transparency

As affect of AI in music creation continues to increase, listeners need to understand how the sounds they love are made — and artists deserve the prospect to elucidate it.

Easy-to-understand AI music labels would flip disclosure into one thing past compliance: it may additionally invite listeners to suppose extra deeply in regards to the artistic course of behind the music they love.