Your Cellphone Is a Slot Machine

This is an version of Time-Travel Thursdays, a journey by way of The Atlantic’s archives to contextualize the current. Sign up here.

Even earlier than the legendary gunslinger Wild Bill Hickok was shot useless holding aces and eights at a Deadwood poker desk, the follow of playing—as a pastime and an enterprise—has been certain up in American id.

But for so long as some Americans have beloved playing, others have judged it. All of the cockfighters, lottery contributors, and sailors throwing scrimshaw cube needed to work across the moral code imposed by Quakers, Shakers, and Puritans who vehemently opposed these video games of likelihood. Gambling has been intermittently banned throughout this country’s history. (By the 1830s, lotteries have been banned outright in most states.) The consequence was a sure cultural ambivalence: Gambling was widespread regardless of being morally out-of-bounds. It was even as soon as part of American politics—within the nineteenth century, earlier than the arrival of dependable polling, folks would place public bets on electoral outcomes as a type of electioneering.

The critics took a wide range of approaches. In the December 1907 problem of The Atlantic, the Unitarian minister Charles F. Dole argued that “the long and costly experience of mankind bears uniform testimony against gambling, till at last the verdict of civilization has become as nearly unanimous as human judgment can be that it is an intolerable nuisance.” Even the standard church raffle, he proposed, flirts with an inherent ethical hazard: “We have no right to expect to receive when we give no equivalent return.”

In the April 1962 problem, Robert F. Kennedy condemned playing not for its ethical valence however for its inevitable connection to organized crime. His view was that the manufacturing facility employee filling out a basketball parlay card at an area lunch counter was in some sense complicit. “Once the housewife, the factory worker, or the business executive gives money to a local bookie or policy writer, it disappears into the pocket of the underworld figure, who is in business to cheat the government—and his customer, if he can,” wrote Kennedy. In a 2010 story, Thomas Sugrue framed playing as an engine of social inequity, taking purpose on the ubiquity of up to date state-sponsored lotteries. (Most states now run their very own lotteries, which ship revenues again to native authorities budgets.) Sugrue noticed them as preying on a “great American pathological co-dependency, namely the desperation of tens of millions of mostly working-class folks to escape their financial insecurity.”

Since the emergence of COVID, playing has solely change into extra accessible. Mobile sports betting took off in 2020; analysis from final yr urged that nearly half of men under 50 have an account with an internet sports activities guide. And prediction markets now allow bets on nearly something. Will Donald Trump purchase Greenland? Will Paul Thomas Anderson lastly win the Academy Award for Best Director? Will Jesus return? If it may be formulated as a yes-or-no query, you may in all probability wager on it. And the truth that it’s all accessible on demand solely makes it simpler to lose your shirt.

Gambling is not confined to casinos, horse tracks, or backroom card video games. It’s in every single place—in restaurant chains and gas stations, Super Bowl ads and video video games. This has created new temptations, significantly for the younger folks now being coaxed into placing their weekly allowance towards randomized Call of Duty loot bins and Polymarket wagers. To make sure, there’s something predatory in regards to the methods during which corporations at the moment are “working really hard to separate young guys from their money,” as the author Max Read put it on the Galaxy Brain podcast. But the mixing of on-line playing into day by day life additionally builds on a push-pull that has existed for hundreds of years: the frenzy of risking all of it, and the nagging instinct that it may be higher to not.